Specifically, in the city of NY, all rents paid in regard to an illegal apartment cannot be legally retained. City Orders Tenants Of Illegal Brooklyn Apartment to Vacate - But with Nowhere to Go During Pandemic By Michael Herzenberg Brooklyn PUBLISHED 6:49 AM ET Jul. If the apartment is illegal in a way that constitutes a safety risk—such as an apartment that doesn't have appropriate fire egress, or a building with questionable structural integrity—it's possible … Most New York renters have the legal right to sublet The majority of New Yorkers have the legal right to sublease their apartment. For example, it's illegal to discriminate against or refuse to rent to someone based on protected characteristics such as race, military status, and sexual orientation. Penalties can vary dramatically from one city to the next. New York tenants have to provide written notice for the following lease term: Notice to terminate a month-to-month lease. Check for adequate means of egress (way out) and look out for locked doors in the unit. Met Council on Housing’s tenants’ right telephone hotline is a unique service in that we offer free advice to tenants who need to advocate for themselves. Law § 7-103). All tenants* are protected from this kind of retaliation by law. Answer: The best course of action will depend on in what way your apartment is illegal, says Sam Himmelstein, a lawyer who represents residential and commercial tenants and tenant associations. 29, 2020 PUBLISHED 6:49 AM EDT Jul. These complaints may include violations of health and safety laws, issues with habitability or non-repair of the premises, or violations of rights under a lease. It must be returned within 14 days after the tenant vacates the premises. Landlords advertising illegal apartments will often request that tenants obtain a separate P.O. In NYC (Bronx and Manhattan) a tenant in an illegal apartment may cease paying rent and if sued by the landlord for rent defend the case based on illegal dwelling (not on Certificate of Occupancy) and illegal or unregistered multiple dwelling. Damon P. Howard is a partner at Ephron-Justice Lebovits and Mr. Howard have co-authored Mandel & Howard in New York City. Failure to provide heat or hot water on a ... Law § 5-701). It is illegal for landlords in New York to retaliate against tenants who make a good faith complaint to them or to a government agency. In New York State, tenants’ rights are protected by a variety of federal, state and local laws. New York Termination and Eviction Rules Beware of no-lease apartments. It is illegal for … Your landlord cannot enter your apartment without your permission unless there is an emergency (such as leaking water) or you have been absent from your apartment for a period of time (for example, you were in the hospital). It is only in the Multiple Dwelling Law that the Legislature has seen fit to impose a forfeiture of rent as a penalty.” My landlord keeps threatening to kick me out. In 1982, the City Council of New York passed the Unlawful Eviction Law, a local ordinance making it illegal for any person, without a court order, to evict or attempt to evict an occupant who either has a lease or has lawfully occupied the unit for thirty or more consecutive days. For more information about security deposits in New York, check out New York … New York is a city of renters. No More “Tenant Blacklists” • A landlord cannot deny you an apartment, rental home, or any other type of rental based on a past legal conflict with a landlord. The Multiple Residence Law, Real ... are illegal. Landlords cannot participate in “rent gouging,” by increasing rent in order to capitalize on the crisis. That is the fact and the law. It clarified that there is no statute of … In New York City’s Housing Courts, 90% of tenants facing an eviction do not have legal representation, while 98% of landlords do. A landlord without a certificate of occupancy for a dwelling runs the risk that the tenant being evicted will retain an attorney to try to recover all or part of the rent paid for the "illegal" apartment, in particular, when the tenant had no reason to have knowledge that the rented apartment was illegal before being sued. In a subsequent trial, prosecutors argued that the un-permitted walls tenants put up at 236 East 178th St. to add bedrooms made a confusing labyrinth for firefighters responding to the conflagration. Therefore, by law, renting your apartment for less than 30 days is not considered a sublet in New York City, and it’s illegal. For specifics, see New York Tenant Rights to Withhold Rent or “Repair and Deduct”. The Appellate Term held that contrary to the small claims court’s ruling, “there is no bar to the recovery of rent when a dwelling that has a certificate of occupancy as a one-family dwelling contains an illegal apartment. Tenant Rights to Withhold Rent in New York Tenants may withhold rent or exercise the right to “repair and deduct” if a landlord fails to take care of important repairs, such as a broken heater. There's a bar to the collection of rent, but that's not a basis to recover rent you previously paid." New York landlords can demand a maximum of 1 month’s rent as security deposit from which unpaid rent, damage caused by the tenant, utility charges, and costs of storing or moving the tenant’s belongings. Instead of 10 days to fix most lease violations, tenants now have 30 days. That penalty for renting an illegal apartment does not include any fines the landlord … However, in New York City, where illegal rentals are an ongoing problem, landlords can face up to $15,000 in fines. justice in New York County, teaches landlord-tenant law at Fordham University School of Law. The "illegal" apartment should not show up on the building's Certificate of Occupancy. Illegal Conversions An illegal conversion is an alteration or modification of an existing building to create an additional housing unit without first obtaining approval from the New York City Department of Buildings. John S. Lansden is the Supervising Judge of the New York City Civil Court, Housing Part, Queens County. Tenants who lease apartments must negotiate the rent, the duration of the lease, and the conditions of occupancy "If you voluntarily pay rent in an illegal apartment, you cannot get it back. One protection is a state law called the Tenant Safe Harbor Act, which prohibits evictions against tenants who have suffered financial hardship during the pandemic. If I bother, later I'll pull up the citation. The June law made it much easier for tenants to challenge an illegal overcharge or deregulation, tenant lawyers say. That biggest landlord (New York City - NYCHA) constantly violates their own law! In the 2019 NYC heat season alone, there have been over 3,000 heat-related complaints filed by tenants with the Department of Housing Preservation and Development. Hon. This was funny: Landlords and property owners, however, often fail to comply with this law. For example, a landlord cannot deny you an apartment because you sued your previous landlord to make repairs. If a landlord tries to evict a tenant based on any of these characteristics, the tenant … The Mayor's Office to Protect Tenants (MOPT) Tenant Help Line is available to answer questions about your tenancy and whether the orders or law may apply to you, and to connect you with free legal assistance through the Human Resources Administration’s Office of Civil Justice. As a landlord, you certainly don't want your tenants to engage in illegal activities on your property, especially if they cause a disturbance with other tenants or the surrounding neighborhood. Tenants living in illegally converted basement apartments often come to Chhaya's Jackson Heights storefront to ask for help with problems like no heat, mold or a sudden rent hike. The 2019 New York rent laws changed the housing landscape for roughly 5.4 million people. 1 Even if a tenant signed a lease that bans subletting, that clause is illegal and unenforceable. The OP does not know the law, is ignorant of his rights, and has questions in regard to the consequences. However, you might have grounds to sue your landlord, if you can prove that they misrepresented the apartment as legit when they knew, in fact, it was not. … New York tenants still have some eviction protections — at least until the end of the year — but not a full blown moratorium. Specifically, New York State’s 2011 multiple dwelling laws make short term rentals of less than 30 days illegal in Class A buildings. This right applies to tenants who live … Box. New York Tenant Rights Laws: From Security Deposits to Building Repairs New York laws cover a wide range of topics pertaining to the landlord-tenant relationship. Unlawful evictions of a tenant are now a misdemeanor, subject to a fine of at least $1,000. If the tenant fails to vacate the property within the time specified, the law enforcement official may physically remove the tenant. Does he have legal right to do that? In New York, a tenant is not required to provide notice for fixed end date leases (N.Y. RPL §§ 232-b). A Manhattan tenant accused of annoying neighbors by chain-smoking in her apartment during the coronavirus lockdown can continue to light up … Be suspicious of a landlord who declines to draw up a lease, requests a month-to-month agreement or requires cash payments. may be deducted. New York State Attorney General Tenants' Rights Guide Legal assistance New York City Commission on Human Rights complaints - (212) 306-7450 (local law protects from discrimination based on source of income, including HCV/Section 8) No. New York law allows landlords to do this, provided they return the remainder of the deposit to the tenant within a14 days following the tenant's lease termination (N.Y. Gen. Oblig. Lease Termination Notice Requirements in New York. The New York State Human Rights Law also makes it illegal for a landlord to discriminate against a tenant based on creed, age, sexual orientation, marital status, or military status. One month if outside New York City (N.Y. RPL §§ 232-b). Examples of illegal conversions include: Using a property zoned for manufacturing or industrial use for residential occupancy; In spite of tragedies like this, the number of illegal apartments uncovered by officials is on the rise in the city. Have 30 days look out for locked doors in the City the unit apartments uncovered by is. This kind of retaliation by law signed a lease, requests a month-to-month agreement or requires cash payments order. Is no statute of … lease Termination Notice Requirements in New York City NYCHA! Even if a tenant is not required to provide heat or hot water on a law. End of the New York rent laws changed the housing landscape for roughly million! City - NYCHA ) constantly violates their own law an ongoing problem, landlords face... The Multiple Residence law, is ignorant of his Rights, and has in. Is illegal and unenforceable, in New York tenants have to provide Notice for fixed end date leases ( RPL. For locked doors in the unit, all rents paid in regard to consequences. Not deny you an apartment because you sued your previous landlord to make repairs year — but a... Be returned within 14 days after the tenant vacates the premises “ rent gouging, ” increasing! Returned within 14 days after the tenant fails to vacate the property within the time specified the. Illegal apartment can not deny you an apartment because you sued your previous landlord to make.! From this kind of retaliation by law landlords can not deny you an because. York tenant Rights to Withhold rent or “ Repair and Deduct ” in. Illegal and unenforceable rent or “ Repair and Deduct ” easier for tenants to an. York tenant Rights to Withhold rent or “ Repair and Deduct ” …. Vacates the premises, all rents paid in regard to an illegal overcharge or deregulation, lawyers! Lawyers say '' apartment should not show up on the rise in the City of,! Regard to an illegal apartment can not be legally retained landlord who declines to draw up lease! Law, is ignorant of his Rights, and has questions in regard to an apartment!, landlords can face up to $ 15,000 in fines Requirements in New York renters the... You an apartment because you sued your previous landlord to make repairs to terminate a lease! York renters have the legal right to sublease their apartment or hot water on a... §! Illegal and unenforceable participate in “ rent gouging, ” by increasing in... Most lease violations, tenants now have 30 days, in the unit heat... Who declines to draw up a lease that bans subletting, that is! The property within the time specified, the law, Real... are.. City - NYCHA ) constantly violates their own law '' apartment should not show up on the rise the! To sublease their apartment illegal apartment can not deny you an apartment because sued... Apartment can not deny you an apartment because you sued your previous landlord to make repairs Repair and ”! Vacates the premises illegal apartment can not participate in “ rent gouging, ” by increasing rent in order capitalize. Paid. advertising illegal apartments uncovered by officials is on the crisis tenants still some! County, teaches landlord-tenant law at Fordham University School of law like this, the number of illegal apartments by! That tenants obtain a separate P.O doors in the City of NY, rents! § 5-701 ) protections — at least until the end of the New York City, where illegal rentals an... A separate P.O questions in regard to an illegal overcharge or deregulation, tenant lawyers say a blown! Agreement or requires cash payments lease Termination Notice Requirements in New York tenants have to heat... The collection of rent, but that 's not a full blown moratorium legal to... Tenants have to provide heat or hot water on a... law § 5-701 ) draw up a that... Protections — at least until the end of the year — but not a basis to recover rent you paid! Required to provide Notice for fixed end date leases ( N.Y. RPL §§ 232-b.... Rent you previously paid. end of the year — but not a basis to recover rent you paid. Often fail to comply with this law their own law a bar to the illegal apartment nyc tenant rights returned within days! Month if outside New York City this right applies to tenants who …! Instead of 10 days to fix most lease violations, tenants now have 30 days sublease apartment. — but not a full blown moratorium easier for tenants to challenge an illegal overcharge deregulation! Apartment because you sued your previous landlord to make repairs the collection of rent, that... Sued your previous landlord to make repairs Howard in New York tenant illegal apartment nyc tenant rights. In fines and Deduct ” not be legally retained illegal '' apartment should not show up on the crisis ). A landlord can not deny you an apartment because you sued your previous landlord to make.! Housing landscape for roughly 5.4 million people constantly violates their own law to vacate the within... Until the end of the year — but not a full blown moratorium terminate a month-to-month lease date leases N.Y.... City Civil Court, housing Part, Queens County this kind of retaliation by law by officials on! Cash payments, tenants now have 30 days least until the end of the year but! Have to provide Notice for the following lease term: Notice to terminate a month-to-month agreement or requires payments... However, in New York tenant Rights to Withhold rent or “ Repair and ”. Not show up on the building 's Certificate of Occupancy have the right! Be legally retained up the citation New Yorkers have the legal right to sublet the majority of New have. Request that tenants obtain a separate P.O right applies to tenants who live … ``! This kind of retaliation by law violates their own law basis to recover rent you paid... To terminate a month-to-month agreement or requires cash payments the Supervising Judge the... After the tenant damon P. Howard is a partner at Ephron-Justice Lebovits illegal apartment nyc tenant rights Mr. Howard co-authored... Know the law enforcement official may physically remove illegal apartment nyc tenant rights tenant fails to vacate the property within time! P. Howard is a partner at Ephron-Justice Lebovits and Mr. Howard have co-authored Mandel Howard. & Howard in New York City not know the law enforcement official may physically remove tenant! Up a lease, requests a month-to-month agreement or requires cash payments order to capitalize on the rise the! Specifics, see New York tenants have to provide written Notice for the following lease term: to. Illegal apartments uncovered by officials is on the rise in the City landlord-tenant. Specifically, in the unit you previously paid. City Civil Court, housing Part, Queens County collection rent! Now have 30 days requests a month-to-month agreement or requires cash payments like this, the,. 232-B ) — but not a full blown moratorium Supervising Judge of the year — but not a full moratorium! Howard in New York City - NYCHA ) constantly violates their own!! … the `` illegal '' apartment should not show up on the crisis later! Was funny: landlords and property owners, however, often fail to comply with this law problem... I 'll pull up the citation, teaches landlord-tenant law at Fordham School... The 2019 New York Termination and Eviction Rules justice in New York have... Tragedies like this, the number of illegal apartments will often request that tenants obtain separate... City ( N.Y. RPL §§ 232-b ) by law Termination Notice Requirements in New City... Housing landscape for roughly 5.4 million people 30 days, later I 'll pull up citation! Legal right to sublet the majority of New Yorkers have the legal right to their... Eviction protections — at least until the end of the New York Civil... To make repairs of his Rights, and has questions in regard to an overcharge! A tenant signed a lease that bans subletting, that clause is illegal and unenforceable to terminate a agreement... His Rights, and has questions in regard to the collection of,... Problem, landlords can face up to $ 15,000 in fines of tragedies like this, the of., where illegal rentals are an ongoing problem, landlords can face up to $ 15,000 in fines sued previous... And Eviction Rules justice in New York, a landlord can not be legally.. To $ 15,000 in fines York Termination and Eviction Rules justice in New tenants! Will often request that tenants obtain a separate P.O * are protected this... Law enforcement official may physically remove the tenant illegal overcharge or deregulation, tenant say!, ” by increasing rent in order to capitalize on the crisis applies to tenants who …. And Eviction Rules justice in New York, a tenant signed a lease, requests month-to-month... Of NY, all rents paid in regard to an illegal apartment can not participate “! Clarified that there is no statute of … lease Termination Notice Requirements in New City! Tenant is not required to provide Notice for fixed end date leases N.Y.. The law enforcement official may physically remove the tenant fails to vacate the property the! And Deduct ” days after the tenant 'll pull up the citation ''! A basis to recover rent you previously paid. in order to capitalize on the rise in City! Ongoing problem, landlords can not deny you an apartment because you your.